These Paleo Maple Caramel Pecan Turtles are made with real honey and maple syrup - so much healthier than regular turtle candies. They make the perfect addition to a tray of Paleo Christmas candies too!
I've spent an entire lifetime detesting caramel. It's ridiculous, but true. I hated it so much, I secretly judged people who could bring themselves to slather perfectly wonderful apple slices in something as horrid as caramel sauce.
I hated the stuff - right up until this spring, when a happy culinary accident brought me to my senses, and made me realize what I've been missing all my life.
Turns out, I love caramel. It's the icky artificial kinds with unpronounceable additives that I can't stand.
That realization opened up a whole new world of treat-making adventures for the kids and I. There is no reason that caramel has to be made with a long list of terrible ingredients! It can be made simply, with real ingredients like coconut oil and maple syrup. There's no reason good caramel can't be paleo.
So we've been doing some experimenting, and a whole bunch of recipes for paleo caramel treats will be coming your way over the next few weeks. Paleo caramel, made with real honey and maple syrup, has truly become one of my favorite indulgences.
Of all the recipes we've been working on, this one here is my favorite, and the one I've been most excited to share!
Everything about these little homemade caramel pecan turtles makes me just love them. From the deep nutty crunch of fresh pecans, to the soft maple sweetness of the caramel, to the smooth finish of dark chocolate. These are everything I could dream of in a candy.
Making them is also a great family activity! Little hands love arranging the pecans in turtle shapes, while Mama whisks the caramel. It's fun coming up with other shapes too - there's honestly no reason they have to resemble the traditional turtle!
When I'm making these Paleo turtle candies, I mostly make them in the traditional size and shape - but I also try to include plenty of little ones. Clusters of just 2 or 3 small pecans covered with the caramel and chocolate, are a nice size for smaller appetites.
These turtle candies are a substantial treat, and even though they're paleo, they're still sweet. It's nice for folks who are watching their sugars to be able to sample these special treats without having to indulge in a whole one.
These paleo caramel pecan turtles are definitely going on our must-make Christmas candy list this year! I hope your family loves them as much as we do!
Bon Appétit!
📖 Recipe
Paleo Maple Pecan Turtles
Equipment
- double boiler
- Cookie sheets
- parchment paper
Ingredients
- ½ cup honey
- ⅓ cup maple syrup
- ½ cup coconut oil (or ¼c coconut oil & ¼c grass-fed butter)
- ¼ cup water
- 8 ounces pecan halves
- 8 ounces dark chocolate
Instructions
- Line cookie sheets with parchment paper. Arrange pecans in clusters on cookie sheets, with ample space between clusters. For the traditional "turtle" shape, put two large pecans end to end for the head and tail, with four small pecan for the legs.
- Once pecans are all arranged, make the caramel. Add all honey, maple syrup, coconut oil, and water to the top of a double boiler. Bring to a simmer over medium-low heat.
- Continue to simmer, stirring frequently. As the mixture cooks, you'll notice that it first darkens in color, and begins to “pull away” from the sides of the pan. You will
likely see an increase in the volume of bubbling right before this point. Soon after, the caramel will start to lighten in color a bit, and that's when you're going to want to pay very close attention - it means you're really just about done. Cooking the caramel takes some time - usually at least 20 minutes. Caramel can be cooked more quickly in a saucepan directly on a burner, but it's a bit easier to burn it, so I suggest using the double boiler. - Heat the caramel till it reaches 245 degrees on a candy thermometer. You can also check for done-ness using the "cold water test": using a spoon, pour a drop of the mixture into a glass of cold water. Mixture should form a ball that stays together, but is still pliable. (We're going for just past the "soft ball" stage.) If mixture strings out in the water rather than forming a ball, cook for a minute or two longer and try again.
- Remove caramel from the heat, and let it rest for a few minutes before spooning it carefully onto the pecan clusters. It's easiest to work with when it's begun to cool just slightly.
- Once you've spooned the caramel onto all of the pecan clusters, let it set while you melt the chocolate.
- Melt the chocolate in a small pan over simmering water. Once melted, spoon on top of caramel-covered pecan clusters.
- For best results, let turtle candies cool undisturbed at room temperature for about 30 minutes.
- Store turtle candies between parchment paper in airtight containers. If the weather is warm, you may want to refrigerate them. I've stored these for up to 48 hours, and they've kept their flavor and texture perfectly. While I've heard that homemade turtle candies can be successfully stored for up to two weeks, I can't imagine having that kind of self-restraint, so we're just going to have to speculate about that one.
Notes
Nutrition
Looking for more seafood recipes? You might like:
✦ Grilled Salmon with Mango Lime Chutney
✦ Mediterranean Tuna Spring Rolls
✦ Keto Shrimp Tacos
✦Orange & Ginger Salmon with Tzatziki
Anna Chesley
Anna Chesley is a freelance writer living a homestead lifestyle, with a special love for family travel, old books, vintage skills, and seaside living. In addition to founding Salt In My Coffee, she runs the website, New England Family Life, as well as The 1800's Housewife, a website devoted to re-creating authentic 1800's recipes.
Victoria says
This was phenomenal thank you! All of the family was surprised this was paleo and much healthier as the flavor wasn't sacrificed. we will make this again !
Anna Chesley says
Thanks for the kind words, Victoria! These are one of our absolute favorites too!
Carla says
I can't have dairy or cane sugar, so these are the perfect stand ins for turtles I would buy at the store. I make them with chocolate that is sweetened with coconut sugar. Using Manuka honey has given them the best flavor so far! I only buy it at Costco or Trader Joe's since it's expensive. I usually have to cook the caramel longer, but check it frequently after about 25-30 min and I usually double the batch. I have only made the caramel straight in a non-stick pot, but use a small double boiler for the chocolate. Once they have cooled, I cut parchment paper in squares and stack them and store them in sandwich ziplocks in the fridge or freezer.
Keri Cooper says
My daughter is allergic to coconut. I typically sub grass fed butter or spectrum palm for coconut oil in recipes. Do you think that would work for the caramel?
Anna says
Yes! I know butter works wonderfully (I’ve done this), and expect that the spectrum palm oil would work as well!
Glenda Griest says
I used a double broiler with med low heat and couldn’t get temp over 207. It took 1hr to get to that temperature. I finished on the stove top. Questioning my success
Carla says
I had made these several times and you do have to be careful not using a double boiler, but they are so good when you get them right! I use Guittard chocolate chips made with coconut sugar!
Carla says
Thanks for the recipe using maple syrup and honey as sweeteners! I used Guittard chocolate chips sweetened with coconut sugar. I made these 3 times and they have gone well 2/3--the last time I must have cooked the caramel too long and it hardened after it cooled. Great recipe to make a version of the ones I was buying in the store that contain cane sugar.